Abraham’s First Failure: Egypt and the Wife-Sister Deception

Abraham’s first failure occurred just a few years after his divine call to leave his homeland and journey to Canaan. This failure resulted directly from a severe famine that struck Canaan—a famine so harsh that it compelled Abraham to make the critical decision to seek food and refuge in Egypt. The writer of Genesis emphasizes the seriousness of this crisis by mentioning the famine twice in Genesis 12:10, highlighting its role as the catalyst for the events that followed.

Archaeological evidence shows that during severe droughts and famines, many people from Canaan and nearby regions migrated to Egypt in search of food. Egypt’s unique geographical position made it a natural refuge during such times. The Nile River’s waters, which flood predictably each year, turn the land into a highly fertile and productive area, enabling the cultivation of food and grain even when surrounding regions face drought and famine. This pattern happened repeatedly throughout biblical history. During another major famine in Canaan generations later, Jacob sent his sons to Egypt to buy grain, illustrating that Egypt remained the main source of relief during agricultural crises (Genesis 42:2).

Abraham’s Perilous Decision

Abraham traveled to Egypt with his extended family because he was certain he would find the food needed to support his household and livestock. However, choosing to enter Egypt in such desperate circumstances left Abraham and his family in a very vulnerable position. As Westermann accurately notes, “As one who has to beg for food, Abraham has no rights” (Westermann 1984:164). During famines, foreign refugees seeking safety in Egypt were often completely at the mercy of Egyptian border troops and officials responsible for defending Egypt’s borders and controlling the flow of desperate migrants.

The Egyptian government was well aware of the economic leverage they held during times of regional famine. They could demand exorbitant prices for food and grain, knowing that desperate refugees had no choice but to pay whatever was asked. Abraham understood that Egyptian officials would extract as much wealth as possible before allowing him and his family to settle temporarily in Egypt for the duration of the famine. His household included his wife Sarah, various servants, and livestock. Abraham was willing to pay whatever price the Egyptians demanded to ensure his family’s survival during their stay in Egypt.

However, Abraham also understood that there was an even higher cost than just money to gain access to Egypt’s fertility and abundance. Foreigners entering Egypt faced strict scrutiny, the risk of losing possessions through confiscation or bribes, the threat of imprisonment, and even the danger of death. Egypt’s powerful army and formidable strength instilled fear in its enemies and created deep uncertainty for those seeking to live under Egyptian protection. Those looking for safety within Egypt’s borders were at the mercy of Egyptian officials who would not hesitate to use force to extract bribes or to seize some of their possessions outright.

The Deception: Abraham’s Plan to Survive

The dialogue between Abraham and Sarah recorded in Genesis 12:1113 reveals the immediate danger Abraham perceived as he prepared to enter Egypt:

“When he was about to enter Egypt, he said to his wife Sarai, ‘I know well that you are a woman beautiful in appearance; and when the Egyptians see you, they will say, “This is his wife”; then they will kill me, but they will let you live. Say you are my sister, so that it may go well with me because of you, and that my life may be spared on your account.’”

Abraham was genuinely afraid for his life, and his fear was well-founded. He knew from experience and reputation that a powerful ruler would not hesitate to take a beautiful woman from another man to satisfy his desires, removing any obstacle in his way. The Old Testament offers clear examples of such actions. King David, when he desired Bathsheba, arranged for her husband Uriah to be killed in battle so he could take her as his wife. Abraham understood that if Pharaoh or his officials wanted Sarah, her being a married woman would not protect her—it would only put Abraham’s life at risk.

By asking Sarah to claim that she was his sister, Abraham was effectively surrendering his wife to another man. Although Genesis records no verbal response from Sarah, her silence indicates her agreement with Abraham’s request, perhaps born of the same fear that gripped her husband. Abraham chose this course of action because he recognized that deception was the only strategy he could conceive to keep himself and his family alive in this dangerous situation.

Yet in making this decision, Abraham revealed a significant spiritual failure. He did not consider the possibility of divine intervention. He did not turn to God in prayer, seeking guidance or deliverance. He did not appear in this moment as a man of faith who trusted in the God who had called him out of Ur and promised to bless him. As Westermann perceptively writes, “He does not think of an intervention of God; he does not appear here as a man of faith. Faced with the threat of death, he surrenders what he ought not surrender” (Westermann 1984:164). In his fear, Abraham relied entirely on his own cunning rather than on divine providence.

The Plan Unfolds: Sarah Taken by Pharaoh

What Abraham feared came to pass exactly as he had predicted, but more completely than he might have imagined. When Abraham and Sarah entered Egypt, the Egyptians immediately noticed that Sarah was a woman of exceptional beauty (Genesis 12:14). The officials of Pharaoh, whose responsibility included identifying anything of value that might please their monarch, also observed Sarah’s remarkable beauty. They praised her appearance to Pharaoh, recommending her as a suitable addition to his household.

When Pharaoh saw Sarah and noticed her beauty for himself, he did exactly what Abraham expected: he took her into his house to become his wife (Genesis 12:15). This was not a temporary arrangement or a trial run. The passage is clear and straightforward: Pharaoh made Sarah his wife. This was a full marriage contract in every legal and social way recognized in the ancient world.

Abraham, believing his deception had succeeded in saving his life, accepted the situation he had arranged. Because the Egyptians thought that Sarah was Abraham’s sister rather than his wife, Abraham’s life was spared. Additionally, due to Sarah, events turned out favorably for Abraham in terms of material gain. Pharaoh, following the usual practice of paying a bride price to the family of a woman he wanted to marry, gave Abraham generous gifts as compensation for his “sister.” Abraham received sheep, oxen, male donkeys, male and female slaves, female donkeys, and camels—a substantial wealth that would make him a wealthy man.

The Catastrophic Consequences

However, the preservation of Abraham’s life and the acquisition of material wealth came at a catastrophic cost that Abraham either failed to fully understand or chose to ignore in his desperation. Abraham’s marriage to Sarah was effectively dissolved. Another man—and not just any man, but Pharaoh, the most powerful ruler in the known world—had taken Sarah as his lawful wife. More critically, God’s promise that Abraham’s descendants would become a great nation and that through him all the families of the earth would be blessed was now in serious danger.

This represents Abraham’s first and most significant failure. By surrendering Sarah to Pharaoh as a wife, Abraham placed the entire divine promise in mortal danger. If Sarah became pregnant with Pharaoh’s child, the promised seed would not come through Abraham. The covenant would be broken, not by God’s unfaithfulness, but by Abraham’s failure to trust and protect what God had entrusted to him. The son who was to carry the blessing to all nations would be born to Pharaoh, an Egyptian ruler, rather than to Abraham, the chosen recipient of God’s promise.

The text makes clear that this was not merely a potential threat but an imminent reality. Pharaoh had taken Sarah as his wife in the full sense of that term. In the normal course of events, Sarah would have been expected to consummate this marriage and, in time, likely would have conceived a child by Pharaoh. The promise given to Abraham in Genesis 12:1–3 would have been nullified, not through any failure on God’s part, but through Abraham’s lack of faith and his willingness to sacrifice his wife to preserve his own life.

God’s Intervention: Preserving the Promise

It is precisely at this critical juncture, when the promise stood on the brink of destruction, that God intervened decisively to rescue both Sarah and the divine plan. Genesis 12:17 records, “But the LORD afflicted Pharaoh and his house with great plagues because of Sarai, Abram’s wife.” God sent severe plagues upon Pharaoh and his entire household specifically because of Sarah, identified here significantly as “Abram’s wife,” not as Abram’s sister.

These plagues served multiple purposes. First, they prevented the consummation of Pharaoh’s marriage to Sarah, ensuring she would not become pregnant with Pharaoh’s child. The intensity and severity of these plagues were enough to warn Pharaoh that something was seriously wrong—that his taking of this woman had brought divine displeasure upon his household. Second, the plagues somehow revealed to Pharaoh the true nature of the situation—that Sarah was not Abraham’s sister but his wife. Whether through prophetic revelation, investigation prompted by the calamity, or direct divine disclosure, Pharaoh came to realize that he had been deceived and that this deception was the reason for his household’s suffering.

God’s intervention was not just an act of mercy toward Abraham, though it was certainly that. It was mainly an act of faithfulness to his own promise. God had committed himself to blessing all nations through Abraham’s descendants. When Abraham’s failure threatened to derail that guarantee, God stepped in to protect what Abraham had jeopardized. The promised seed would indeed come through Abraham and Sarah, but only because God refused to let human failure stop divine purpose.

Abraham’s Humiliation and Expulsion

Once Pharaoh learned about the deception Abraham had carried out, he summoned Abraham and confronted him directly about his wrongdoing. Pharaoh’s words are filled with justified anger and moral outrage: “What is this you have done to me? Why did you not tell me that she was your wife? Why did you say, ‘She is my sister,’ so that I took her for my wife? Now then, here is your wife, take her, and leave” (Genesis 12:18–19).

The irony of this situation is devastating. Pharaoh, a pagan ruler who did not worship the God of Abraham, holds moral authority, while Abraham, the man called by God to bless all nations, is shown as a liar and deceiver. Abraham, who was meant to bring blessing to the Gentile nations, instead brought plagues upon Pharaoh’s household. Abraham, who was called to show faith in the one true God, instead displayed faithlessness and a desire for self-preservation at any cost.

Abraham offers no response to Pharaoh’s reproach. He remains completely silent before this accusation because he knows he is guilty of every charge leveled against him. Abraham’s silence is a clear sign of his shame and his awareness of his failure to be a blessing to Pharaoh as God intended. His silence condemns him more powerfully than any words could. He has no defense to make, no justification to offer, no excuse to give. He can only stand in humiliated silence before the man he has wronged.

As a direct result of Abraham’s deception, Pharaoh expelled Abraham from Egypt. Pharaoh made sure Abraham left his country by sending an armed escort, ensuring that this troublesome foreigner would indeed exit Egyptian territory: “And Pharaoh gave his men orders concerning him; and they set him on the way, with his wife and all that he had” (Genesis 12:20). Abraham, who had come to Egypt hoping to find food and safety, was now forced to leave in disgrace, expelled by a pagan king who proved to be more honorable than the man of God.

The Nature of Abraham’s First Failure

Abraham’s journey to Egypt represents his first comprehensive failure after receiving God’s call and promise. This failure was not a single misstep but a cascade of faithless decisions, each one compounding the previous error.

First, Abraham failed to trust in God to provide for him and his family. When confronted with the famine in Canaan, Abraham did not seek God’s guidance or wait for divine provision. Instead, he immediately looked to human solutions, deciding on his own initiative: “He went to Egypt.” Abraham forgot that the God who had called him out of Ur, who had promised to make him a great nation, who had pledged to bless all families of the earth through him, was surely capable of providing food during a famine. Abraham’s decision to flee to Egypt without divine direction demonstrated a fundamental lack of trust in God’s care and faithfulness.

Second, Abraham failed to be a blessing to Pharaoh; instead, he brought deception and divine judgment. God had called Abraham with the explicit promise that through him, all the families of the earth would be blessed (Genesis 12:3). Pharaoh was one of those families. Yet instead of bringing blessing to this Gentile ruler, Abraham brought lies and plagues. By telling Sarah, “Say you are my sister,” Abraham set in motion a chain of events that would result in divine judgment falling upon an innocent man and his household. Pharaoh, who had dealt generously with Abraham based on the information he had been given, became the victim of Abraham’s deception rather than the beneficiary of Abraham’s blessing.

Third, Abraham’s self-interest endangered Sarah and put God’s promise in jeopardy. Abraham’s reasoning was brutally self-centered: “that my life may be spared on your account.” He was willing to surrender his wife to another man, to allow her to be taken into Pharaoh’s harem and bed, to risk her bearing another man’s child—all to preserve his own life. In doing so, Abraham failed in his most basic responsibility as a husband to protect and honor his wife. More critically, he failed in his responsibility as the bearer of God’s promise to safeguard the means by which that promise would be fulfilled.

The Promise in Jeopardy

The most serious consequence of Abraham’s failure, however, was not his personal humiliation but the jeopardy in which he placed God’s promise. God had promised Abraham that he would become the father of a great nation and that through his offspring all the families of the earth would be blessed. This promise required that Abraham have a son through Sarah, his wife. Yet Abraham’s actions threatened to make this promise impossible to fulfill.

By giving Sarah to Pharaoh as a wife, Abraham created a situation in which Sarah might well have conceived a child by Pharaoh rather than by Abraham. Had this occurred, the entire promise would have been thrown into question. Who would be Abraham’s heir? Would it be a son born to Sarah but fathered by Pharaoh? Would such a child be the one through whom all nations would be blessed? The very foundation of the covenant was at risk because of Abraham’s faithless decision.

The only reason Sarah did not become pregnant with Pharaoh’s child was because God intervened directly and powerfully. The plagues that God sent upon Pharaoh’s household aimed to bring Sarah back to Abraham before any lasting damage could be done to the promise. God’s intervention was not optional or minor—it was absolutely necessary. Without divine action, Abraham’s failure would have completely derailed the covenant promise.

God’s Faithfulness in the Face of Human Failure

This episode reveals a profound theological truth: God’s promises are ultimately based on divine faithfulness, not human faithfulness. Abraham failed spectacularly. He showed a lack of faith, selfishness, a willingness to deceive, and an eagerness to sacrifice his wife and God’s promise to save his own life. Yet, God did not abandon Abraham or revoke His promise. Instead, God stepped in to rescue Abraham from the results of his own faithlessness and to ensure the promise could still be fulfilled.

This was the first time God had to intervene to deliver Abraham and to ensure that his promise would be fulfilled through a son born of Abraham and Sarah. It was the first time Abraham failed God in such a comprehensive and dangerous manner. Tragically, as the subsequent narrative of Genesis reveals, it would not be the last time Abraham would fail, nor would it be the last time God would need to intervene to preserve his promise despite human weakness and sin.

The story of Abraham in Egypt serves as a sobering reminder that even those chosen by God to be the channels of his blessing can experience significant failure. It shows us that faith is not a constant state but must be actively maintained and renewed with each new challenge. It warns us that self-preservation at the expense of others and God’s purposes is never a wise choice, regardless of how dire the circumstances may seem. And it reassures us that God’s plans cannot be thwarted by human failure, for he remains faithful even when we are unfaithful.

Abraham’s first failure in Egypt would become a pattern that repeated itself throughout his life and his descendants’. Yet through all these failures, God’s promise would continue to stand, not because of human merit or faithfulness, but because of the unchanging character and unbreakable commitment of the God who makes and keeps his promises.

Completed Studies on Abraham’s Failures

The Five Failures of Abraham (June 14, 2022)
Ur and Haran: Abraham’s Background (February 16, 2023)
The Failures of Faith in Abraham’s Journey
Abraham and Terah: Family Dynamics and Divine Calling
Abraham Before His Call: The Mesopotamian Context
The Call of Abraham: Divine Initiative and Human Response
Abraham and Lot: Separation and Its Implications
God’s Promises to Abraham
Abraham’s First Failure: Egypt and the Wife-Sister Deception
Abraham’s Second Failure: The Eliezer Solution
Abraham’s Third Failure: The Hagar Alternative
Abraham’s Fourth Failure: Laughter at Divine Promise
Abraham’s Fifth Failure: Gerar and Repeated Deception
The Testing of Abraham: From Failure to Faith

NOTE: For a comprehensive list of studies on Abraham, read my post Studies on Abraham.

Bibliography

Westermann, Claus. Genesis 1–11: A Commentary. Translated by John J. Scullion. Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1984.

Claude Mariottini
Emeritus Professor of Old Testament
Northern Baptist Seminary

If you enjoyed reading this post, you will enjoy reading my books.

VISIT MY AMAZON AUTHOR’S PAGE

BUY MY BOOKS ON AMAZON (Click here).

NOTE: Did you like this post? Do you think other people would like to read this post? Be sure to share this post on Facebook and share a link on X so that others may enjoy reading it too!

If you are looking for other series of studies on the Old Testament, visit the Archive section and you will find many studies that deal with a variety of Old Testament topics.