Denial is not forgiveness - Divorce Minister

“For everyone practicing evil hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed.”

– John 3:20, NKJV

Silence about infidelity is the same thing as avoiding the light. 

It says the person does not what his or her wicked deeds exposed. They have not truly embraced repentance and accepted the consequences that follow from choosing evil over righteousness. Instead, they focus their energies at seeking the darkness and running from the light.

Jesus’ words are very applicable to such situations. He calls those people practitioners of evil.

Denial is not the same thing as forgiveness.

I am conflating denial with silence over what took place here. Personally, I do not believe in the “forgive and forget” crowd on these matters. Such thinking is not very attuned to human reality that we do not forget deeply traumatic experiences.

And surviving adultery–even fully forgiven adultery does NOT change this historical fact–is very traumatic!

Plus, I am discouraged to hear/read pastors and Christian leaders encourage silence about infidelity after confession–or not even.

This is not good spiritual counsel.

As people of the Light, we ought to be willing to walk in the light. Silence is a cloak for darkness. Counsel to silence the faithful spouse on these matters is to counsel keeping both the faithful spouse and cheating spouse in darkness. This is ungodly counsel. It provides sin the cover of darkness.

While I do not encourage oversharing, I also do not encourage silence and denial of a major life shaping event like infidelity discovery. Plus, I question if genuine forgiveness can take place under a “cone of silence” regarding infidelity.

Adultery impacts more than just the faithful spouse. It is a community disease. That is clearly how God perceived it in the Old Testament with His command to purge the evil from among His people (see Deuteronomy 22:22).

Similarly, the healing of the community or family cannot take place when they are unaware of essential facts–i.e. that one member committed adultery against the other. I think community aspect is often overlooked here in the USA because of our overemphasis of individualization.

Besides the community issue, I would be concerned regarding true healing for the wronged spouse as the silence call–once again–puts the cheater’s “needs” unjustly before the faithful spouse’s needs (to heal). This does not seem like a recipe for restoration.

It looks more like a recipe for bitterness as an artificial cap is put on the issue and things are rug-swept–e.g. residual grief following the initial adultery confession because of the imposed silence.

When I think of true forgiveness and healing, I picture people who can talk about a wrong openly without the pain or anger originally associated with the sin.

Imposed silence strikes me as a denial that the sin took place or needs additional attention after the initial confession. Infidelity wounds will not generally heal overnight. It is cruel to expect a faithful spouse never to talk about their soul wounds again regarding this sin.

Denial and silence is not forgiveness.

They are ways to give wickedness the cover of darkness.

*A version of this post ran previously.

Give

Subscribe to the Daybreak Devotions for Women

Be inspired by God's Word every day! Delivered to your inbox.


More from David Derksen

  • featureImage

    Cannot put the genie back in the bottle - Divorce Minister

    For the woman’s jealous husband will be furious, and he will show no mercy when he takes revenge. -Proverbs 6:34, NLT In the early stages post-discovery, it is natural to try to wake up from the “bad dream.” Unfortunately, you will learn–painfully–that the genie cannot go back into that bottle. If you are at all … Continue reading "Cannot put the genie back in the bottle"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming - Divorce Minister

    Give honor to marriage, and remain faithful to one another in marriage. God will surely judge people who are immoral and those who commit adultery. -Hebrews 13:4, NLT Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming So, your Cheater admits to an “emotional affair.” They may even do this in the presence of a pastor or counselor. How does … Continue reading "Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    "I protected YOUR reputation! So..." - Divorce Minister

    “I protected YOUR reputation with our friends,” says Cheater. “So, I am asking you to do the same for me.” First, do not believe a proven liar, and Cheaters are proven liars. They are only saying this to control the narrative and protect their image. They assume here the faithful spouse will lie for their … Continue reading "“I protected YOUR reputation! So…”"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    "Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but..." - Divorce Minister

    “Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but you’ve got issues, too,” says false “friend.” You need to lose “friends” that respond in this sort of way to your infidelity trauma. They are not behaving as a friend. In fact, they are making things worse by equating your imperfections with a double-life of lies and … Continue reading "“Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but…”"

    1 min read
  • featureImage

    I don't get it. - Divorce Minister

    I don’t get faithful spouses wanting to be friends with their Cheaters. Sure, there’s pressure to do this “for the kids” if kids are involved. Some may feel pressure from outsiders to do this to not burden them with the ugliness that is reality. It makes sense for Cheaters to want this–i.e. to be “friends.” … Continue reading "I don’t get it."

    1 min read

Editor's Picks

More from David Derksen

  • featureImage

    Cannot put the genie back in the bottle - Divorce Minister

    For the woman’s jealous husband will be furious, and he will show no mercy when he takes revenge. -Proverbs 6:34, NLT In the early stages post-discovery, it is natural to try to wake up from the “bad dream.” Unfortunately, you will learn–painfully–that the genie cannot go back into that bottle. If you are at all … Continue reading "Cannot put the genie back in the bottle"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming - Divorce Minister

    Give honor to marriage, and remain faithful to one another in marriage. God will surely judge people who are immoral and those who commit adultery. -Hebrews 13:4, NLT Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming So, your Cheater admits to an “emotional affair.” They may even do this in the presence of a pastor or counselor. How does … Continue reading "Emotional Affair Back-Handed Blaming"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    "I protected YOUR reputation! So..." - Divorce Minister

    “I protected YOUR reputation with our friends,” says Cheater. “So, I am asking you to do the same for me.” First, do not believe a proven liar, and Cheaters are proven liars. They are only saying this to control the narrative and protect their image. They assume here the faithful spouse will lie for their … Continue reading "“I protected YOUR reputation! So…”"

    2 min read
  • featureImage

    "Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but..." - Divorce Minister

    “Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but you’ve got issues, too,” says false “friend.” You need to lose “friends” that respond in this sort of way to your infidelity trauma. They are not behaving as a friend. In fact, they are making things worse by equating your imperfections with a double-life of lies and … Continue reading "“Yeah, I know she cheated on you, but…”"

    1 min read
  • featureImage

    I don't get it. - Divorce Minister

    I don’t get faithful spouses wanting to be friends with their Cheaters. Sure, there’s pressure to do this “for the kids” if kids are involved. Some may feel pressure from outsiders to do this to not burden them with the ugliness that is reality. It makes sense for Cheaters to want this–i.e. to be “friends.” … Continue reading "I don’t get it."

    1 min read