Prosperity Gospel: Examining controversial teachings

The televangelist proclaims, "Give to the ministry, and the Lord will cancel all your debts!" "The more you give to the church, the more God will bless you financially and in all aspects of your life."

Some televangelists and pastors frequently make promises of debt cancellation and financial blessings in exchange for donations to their ministries. 

They encourage congregants to give generously, claiming that the more one donates to the church, the greater God's financial blessings will be upon them.

Often heard in church gatherings, such claims are characteristic of 'Prosperity Preachers' and other church leaders.

Prosperity Gospel is a theological belief that God wants to bless His people with material prosperity, health, wealth, and success as a reward for their faith. 

It teaches that devotion, positive confessions, and financial contributions will bring earthly blessings and prosperity.

Understanding the Prosperity Gospel

Prosperity Gospel emphasizes that God desires to bless believers with physical health and financial abundance. 

The theology teaches that believers can influence their circumstances through positive confessions, also known as "name it and claim it." They are encouraged to declare their desires aloud, expecting God to fulfill them. 

Additionally, adherents are urged to give generously to their religious leaders as a form of seed-faith offering, with the promise of reaping financial rewards in return.

Biblical claims of the Prosperity Gospel

While attracting a large following, this doctrine has faced criticism for its materialistic emphasis and selective interpretation of scriptures. This belief is often based on a selective reading of specific biblical passages, such as:

"The Lord will grant you abundant prosperity—in the fruit of your womb, the young of your livestock and the crops of your ground—in the land he swore to your ancestors to give you." - Deuteronomy 28:11

The related verses contain promises of blessings for the Israelites if they obey God's commands. These blessings include material prosperity, longevity, success in warfare, and the favor of other nations. 

However, it is essential to note that the passage includes a list of curses that would befall the Israelites if they disobeyed God.

"The blessing of the Lord brings wealth, without painful toil for it." - Proverbs 10:22

In this verse, the term "wealth" can be interpreted as "prosperous" or "successful." 

Thus, the proverb implies that living wisely and adhering to God's commands can lead to overall success, including financial prosperity, in various aspects of life.

Teachings and practices of the Prosperity Gospel

The Abrahamic Covenant of material prosperity

The Abrahamic Covenant in Genesis 12, 15, 17, and 22 serves as a theological foundation for the prosperity gospel.

The idea behind the prosperity gospel is that Christians, as Abraham's spiritual descendants, inherit material blessings through the Abrahamic Covenant. 

It suggests that God's primary purpose was to bless Abraham materially, and as believers, we also receive these financial benefits. 

However, these interpretations vary among Christian denominations and theological perspectives.

While it is positive that prosperity theologians acknowledge the Scriptural fulfillment of the covenant, their interpretation needs to be revised. 

They must understand its inception and, more importantly, misapply its principles. This notion results in an unorthodox view of the covenant and leads to misguided teachings within the context of the prosperity gospel.

Positive confession

Positive confession is a belief that speaking "faith-filled" words grants believers their desires. Its infiltration into the church causes turmoil and confusion.

Proponents of Prosperity Gospel often use verses to justify positive confession. Mark 11:23-24 reads: “Truly I tell you, if anyone says to this mountain, 'Go, throw yourself into the sea,' and does not doubt in their heart but believes that what they say will happen, it will be done for them."

Seed-faith offering

Seed-faith offering explains that giving, or sowing seeds of faith, leads to reaping benefits, citing Mark 11:24. Like a farmer who cultivates the ground and expects a harvest, believers hope for results.

The emphasis on giving in the prosperity gospel may appear admirable. It is centered on calls to meet the needs of humanity and finance the spread of the Gospel worldwide. 

Despite this, criticism arises from the underlying motives. Some argue that the focus on giving is driven more by personal gain and financial prosperity rather than genuine philanthropy and selfless service. 

The debate over the theology and ethics of the prosperity gospel continues among Christians.

Prayer is a tool to have prosperity from God

Prosperity gospel preachers often proclaim we "have not because we ask not" (James 4:2). Prayers for personal blessings are not inherently wrong. 

However, the prosperity gospel's excessive focus on humanity transforms prayer into a means for believers to manipulate God into fulfilling their desires.

In this theology, people become the central point of prayer rather than God. 

Contrarily, prosperity preachers often skip the latter part of James's teaching on prayer: "You ask and do not receive because you ask wrongly, to spend it on your passions" (James 4:3). 

God does not grant selfish requests that dishonor His name.

False Gospel, controversies, and criticisms

A woman praying over young people. (Photo by RDNE Stock project from Pexels)

The prosperity teaching is a false gospel because it is a simplistic and often inaccurate interpretation of the Bible. 

We must remember that the Bible teaches that God's blessings are more than material prosperity. They include things like peace, joy, and eternal life.

1. Materialistic focus

Critics argue that Prosperity Gospel's obsession with wealth and success distracts from the core teachings of Christianity. 

The Bible focuses on spiritual growth, love, and serving others. Preachers commonly use passages like Luke 6:38 to support this practice: "Give, and it will be given to you. A good measure, pressed down, shaken together and running over, will be poured into your lap. For with the measure you use, it will be measured to you." 

The overemphasis on financial and material blessings can result to a self-centered approach to faith.

2. Misinterpretation of Scripture

Detractors point out those Prosperity Gospel preachers often cherry-pick verses to support their teachings. 

They ignore other biblical passages emphasizing the importance of perseverance through trials and tribulations.

3. Lack of empirical evidence

Despite claims of miraculous wealth and healing, critics contend there is little empirical evidence to support the Prosperity Gospel's promises on a broad scale. 

Many followers struggle financially and face health challenges despite their unwavering faith.

4. Exploitation and manipulation

Some Prosperity Gospel preachers have faced allegations of exploiting their followers for personal gain. 

They are accused of pressuring vulnerable individuals to make substantial financial contributions, leading to financial strain and disappointment.

The True Gospel of Giving

People in a discussion. {Photo by Small Group Network from Unsplash)

The prosperity gospel, viewed in light of Scripture, is fundamentally flawed due to its misconceived understanding of the relationship between God and humanity. 

If accepted, it renders grace redundant, diminishes God's significance, and elevates human desires above divine sovereignty.

As a result, it distorts core theological concepts like the Abrahamic covenant, atonement, giving, faith, and prayer, transforming them into mere transactions between man and God. 

Such an approach is profoundly inadequate and deviates from the biblical portrayal of the intimate and sacred relationship between the Creator and His creation. 

Critics argue that this false Prosperity Gospel misguides believers and undermines authentic Christian faith.

The true Gospel of Christ advances the Kingdom of God on earth and the Great Commission compels us to share the Gospel to the ends of the earth. 

Giving is primarily a virtue of propagating evangelism and discipleship so that the aims of Christ, the salvation of humankind, are pursued. We do not give because of selfish interests or returns.

Nothing wrong with wealth, riches, or money. But God detests greed, discontent, and the "love of money."

We give because we hope to imitate Christ and cultivate His identity to express our love for God and others. 

Ultimately, faith should not be centered solely on seeking material gain but on growing in spiritual wisdom and positively impacting the world.

More from Crossmap: The “good” in God’s plan for your life