Podcast – Objections: Why do Bad Things Happen to Good People? With Terry Feix

This is an ancient question that predates the existence of Christ. The existence of evil has plagued humanity since the Garden of Eden. 

The philosopher Plato has an argument called “Euthyphro.” It is a philosophical statement of the existence of evil. While this is not what is commonly talked about, it is a formalized statement. 

It makes these three statements: 

  1. God is all-powerful.

  2. God is good. 

  3.  Evil exists in the world. 

The Euthyphro Argument says only two of those can be true at the same time. If God is all-powerful and all-good, there should be no evil in the world. If God is all-powerful and evil exists in the world, God cannot be good. If God is good and there is evil, God is not all-powerful.  A logically consistent universe demands only two of those three statements be true, making the third option false. 

This is considered an attack against the existence of God. 

When God does not intervene in difficult and evil circumstances, what is he doing? Does he even exist? Is it just, fair, and right? Why do evil people seem to prosper? 

Deconstruct the Doubts

One of the best ways to begin approaching this topic is to deconstruct the preconceived notions about God and the existence of evil. 

In response to Plato’s “Euthyphro,” the question should be asked: “Have you considered another possibility? Have you doubted that way of thinking and considered another perspective?” 

There are four main ways to doubt these doubts in addressing the problem of evil:

  1. We often expect things to go well for us. Suffering is part of life for everyone. It is not abnormal to the human experience.

  2. We often approach God with a sense of entitlement to remove all potential suffering because of how “good” we are.  We ought to be surprised that good things happen to us. 

  3. Suffering is useful for our growth as Christians. We often underestimate the usefulness of suffering in our lives. Suffering is purposeful.

  4. Our suffering is not always about us. 

“For as we share abundantly in Christ's sufferings, so through Christ we share abundantly in comfort too. If we are afflicted, it is for your comfort and salvation; and if we are comforted, it is for your comfort, which you experience when you patiently endure the same sufferings that we suffer. Our hope for you is unshaken, for we know that as you share in our sufferings, you will also share in our comfort.” – 2 Corinthians 1:5-7

Brittany Proffitt lives in Dallas and is a writer and content manager for So We Speak

Give

Subscribe to the Daybreak Devotions for Women

Be inspired by God's Word every day! Delivered to your inbox.


More from Cole Feix

  • featureImage

    Beyond Style: Why Young and Old Need Historic Hymns

    Over the past few weeks, as I have read from - and listened to - my normal pool of both old and dead theologians, I have noticed a common denominator: many of them regularly reference hymn texts in their writings and speaking. Of course, the theological topic being discussed will lend itself to specific hymns, but what I have noticed is an overarching knowledge of hymns that comes out in every facet of their lives. Why is this important? And why would I notice it? Let me try to answer these ques

    7 min read
  • featureImage

    Good, Evil, and Grace

    If you’ve been to the movie theatre recently, you’ve probably seen a lot of promotion for the new Lilo & Stitch movie. Despite how you feel about what the internet has dubbed a controversial ending, I want to take a moment to analyze one of the themes in the film. Throughout the movie, Nani, Lilo’s older sister, is trying to make Lilo and Stitch behave so she can maintain a job and keep legal guardianship of her little sister. However, Stitch seems to mess up Nani’s chances of either of these th

    3 min read
  • featureImage

    Podcast Recap: Why Religion Went Obsolete

    Check out the So We Speak podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Christian Smith’s book, Why Religion Went Obsolete, explores why religion, especially in modern Western societies, is seen as less necessary or even irrelevant. The argument is that with the rise of science, secularism, and modern culture, many people have moved away from traditional religious beliefs. Religion is often viewed as outdated or unable to answer today’s questions about life and meaning. This has led to fewer people pr

    1 min read
  • featureImage

    The Hesed of God, Part 2: The Grace of Forgiveness

    In the first article in this series, we explored God’s hesed toward us in the context of grief and despair. Though life is hard and marked by suffering, believers can rejoice because of God's hesed—His loyal, covenant-keeping love. He not only sees our pain but has entered our trials and suffering through Christ. Through Jesus’ suffering and death, we are brought into God’s faithful love and are never alone in our trials.This flows beautifully into exploring the grace of forgiveness we have rece

    3 min read
  • featureImage

    Podcast -  Villains of the Bible: Nebuchadnezzar

    Check out the So We Speak podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.The worst event in Israel’s history was the destruction of the Temple by the Babylonians in 586 BC. The general in charge of that destruction was Nebuchadnezzar, a king who became an emblem of all those who would elevate themselves against God. Unlike other rulers, we get an up-close look at Nebuchadnezzar in the Book of Daniel. There, we see God humbling and chastening him for his pride and brutality.The Babylonian Empire was short-

    2 min read

Editor's Picks

  • featureImage

    For His Glory (by Cathe Laurie)

    We may not see the results of our faithfulness while on earth. But if we’re working for our own benefit or validation, we’ve missed the point.

    4 min read
  • featureImage

    The Girl Who Doesn’t Like Me and I Don’t Know Why

    She has a name. But in my house, she’s referred to as The-girl-who-doesn’t-like-me-and-I-don’t- know-why. Do you have anyone in your life like that? In social situations, she steers clear of you and refuses to make eye contact. When trying to reach out, you draw back an emotional nub of rejection. You rack your brain trying to figure out what you did to make her dislike you but come up blank. Read more...

    4 min read

More from Cole Feix

  • featureImage

    Beyond Style: Why Young and Old Need Historic Hymns

    Over the past few weeks, as I have read from - and listened to - my normal pool of both old and dead theologians, I have noticed a common denominator: many of them regularly reference hymn texts in their writings and speaking. Of course, the theological topic being discussed will lend itself to specific hymns, but what I have noticed is an overarching knowledge of hymns that comes out in every facet of their lives. Why is this important? And why would I notice it? Let me try to answer these ques

    7 min read
  • featureImage

    Good, Evil, and Grace

    If you’ve been to the movie theatre recently, you’ve probably seen a lot of promotion for the new Lilo & Stitch movie. Despite how you feel about what the internet has dubbed a controversial ending, I want to take a moment to analyze one of the themes in the film. Throughout the movie, Nani, Lilo’s older sister, is trying to make Lilo and Stitch behave so she can maintain a job and keep legal guardianship of her little sister. However, Stitch seems to mess up Nani’s chances of either of these th

    3 min read
  • featureImage

    Podcast Recap: Why Religion Went Obsolete

    Check out the So We Speak podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Christian Smith’s book, Why Religion Went Obsolete, explores why religion, especially in modern Western societies, is seen as less necessary or even irrelevant. The argument is that with the rise of science, secularism, and modern culture, many people have moved away from traditional religious beliefs. Religion is often viewed as outdated or unable to answer today’s questions about life and meaning. This has led to fewer people pr

    1 min read
  • featureImage

    The Hesed of God, Part 2: The Grace of Forgiveness

    In the first article in this series, we explored God’s hesed toward us in the context of grief and despair. Though life is hard and marked by suffering, believers can rejoice because of God's hesed—His loyal, covenant-keeping love. He not only sees our pain but has entered our trials and suffering through Christ. Through Jesus’ suffering and death, we are brought into God’s faithful love and are never alone in our trials.This flows beautifully into exploring the grace of forgiveness we have rece

    3 min read
  • featureImage

    Podcast -  Villains of the Bible: Nebuchadnezzar

    Check out the So We Speak podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.The worst event in Israel’s history was the destruction of the Temple by the Babylonians in 586 BC. The general in charge of that destruction was Nebuchadnezzar, a king who became an emblem of all those who would elevate themselves against God. Unlike other rulers, we get an up-close look at Nebuchadnezzar in the Book of Daniel. There, we see God humbling and chastening him for his pride and brutality.The Babylonian Empire was short-

    2 min read