Controversial issues: How should churches promote unity?

As a Christian, you have likely been a part of church communities that have grappled with controversial issues. These are the topics that spark deep conversations and sometimes disagreements within your congregation. They are the challenges that make you think hard about your faith and values.

You know that churches hold a special place in society. They are not just places of worship; they are where you find a sense of belonging, support, and guidance. 

In our rapidly changing world, where new ideas and perspectives are always emerging, the church's role becomes even more vital. How your church deals with these thorny issues can make a big difference in your life and your community.

In this article, we will tackle all about those controversial issues in churches. 


History of division

Looking back in time, you will find that churches have had their share of controversial issues.

One significant moment of controversy occurred during the Civil Rights Movement. In those days, churches found themselves amid internal debates about racial equality

Some members supported the movement, while others opposed it. This led to tense and heated discussions within the sacred walls of the church. This is much like the divisions within members of the early church. 

One of the earliest and most significant controversies in the early church was the question of whether Gentile converts needed to adhere to Jewish customs and traditions. This includes circumcision and dietary laws. This debate is recorded in the book of Acts (Acts 15) and is often referred to as the Council of Jerusalem

The apostles and early leaders had to deliberate over whether Gentile believers should be subject to these Jewish laws. This division was resolved through a decision that allowed Gentile converts to remain free from these requirements. This emphasized salvation through faith in Christ.


Present-day controversial issues

Nothing much has changed from the past. Like before, churches still face several controversial issues. These contemporary challenges highlight the ever-evolving nature of faith and its engagement with the changing world.

LGBTQ+ rights and inclusion

You might have noticed the ongoing conversations within your church regarding how to embrace and include LGBTQ+ individuals while staying true to your faith. 

This topic touches the hearts of many, as they seek to understand God's love and acceptance for all.

Abortion

Another present-day controversy you may have encountered as a Christian concerns abortion. 

This is a deeply complex and sensitive matter that challenges the church to weigh the sanctity of life against the personal and ethical aspects of this issue. Navigating this discussion can be emotionally charged. 

Questions are raised about when life begins and how to respond with compassion.

Women in leadership

The role of women in church leadership is yet another matter of discussion. 

As a Christian, you might have witnessed debates about the extent of women's participation in pastoral roles, elder positions, and other leadership roles. 

It is an issue where differing biblical interpretations and traditions come into play.

Type of worship music

The style of worship music is another contemporary controversy within Christian congregations. You may have witnessed debates over the type of music used in worship services, from traditional hymns to contemporary praise and worship songs. 

These discussions can touch on matters of reverence, cultural relevance, and personal preference.

Politics from the pulpit

The intersection of politics and faith is a topic that has become increasingly controversial. 

As you sit in church, you may have noticed the delicate balance that your pastor tries to maintain when addressing political issues from the pulpit. 

It is a conversation that involves principles, values, and the desire to avoid division within the congregation.

Theological interpretation and denominational differences

Lastly, theological interpretations and denominational differences continue to create conversations within the Christian community. 

You may find yourself in discussions about differing beliefs and practices among various Christian denominations, emphasizing the need for unity while respecting diversity in the body of Christ. 

These controversies highlight the importance of holding onto your faith while being open to learning and understanding various perspectives within the larger Christian family.


Church responses

In the midst of these modern controversies, you will notice that Christians often respond in diverse ways. Here are some of them.

Conservative vs. progressive 

Within these modern controversies, you will notice that Christians often respond in diverse ways. 

Some take a conservative approach, which means they uphold traditional beliefs and practices. They might argue that certain controversial issues, like the ones we have discussed, should be seen through the lens of age-old doctrine and teachings. 

These individuals value preserving the historical values of the faith and are cautious about change.

On the other hand, some follow a progressive approach. 

They are open to adapting and reinterpreting their faith in light of changing times. 

For them, embracing change and inclusivity is essential, even if it means challenging long-held beliefs. 

Theological frameworks and scriptural interpretation

Your response to these controversies is often influenced by your theological framework and how you interpret scripture. 

Different theological perspectives can lead to varying conclusions on issues like LGBTQ+ inclusion, abortion, or women in leadership. 

Your faith community's interpretation can be deeply rooted in tradition or more open to reevaluating interpretations based on contemporary understanding.

Congregational diversity and local decision-making

Another factor in the diverse responses to these issues is the makeup of your congregation and the local decision-making processes. 

Within your church, you may find a wide range of beliefs and backgrounds. This diversity can influence how your church addresses these controversies. 

Some congregations may engage in open dialogue and decision-making, while others may have a more centralized authority that determines the approach. 

These differences make it clear that every church community is unique, and their responses to these issues reflect their particular dynamics and convictions.


How the church should promote unity

In your Christian journey, promoting unity within your church is essential, especially in the face of controversial issues. It is a path marked by understanding, compassion, and a shared desire to honor your faith while addressing disagreements. 

Here are ways your church can effectively foster unity:

Hear out the congregation

Unity begins with listening. As a church, it is vital to hear what your members have to say about the controversial issues that arise. Make an effort to understand various perspectives and opinions. Being well-informed about all aspects of the issue helps create an environment where everyone's voice is valued.

Expose the root cause

To truly foster unity, it is important to dig deep and expose the root cause of the controversy. Often, disagreements stem from different underlying concerns or misunderstandings. By addressing these fundamental issues, you can work towards a more harmonious congregation.

Work patiently with your members

Unity doesn't happen overnight. It requires patience and dedication. Engage in open conversations with your fellow church members. Acknowledge that it may take time to find common ground. Establishing a safe and patient atmosphere for discussions is vital for building unity.

Be open to the idea that you have faulty solutions

Sometimes, the solutions that seem right at first may not lead to true unity. Be open to the possibility that the initial approaches might be faulty. It is okay to reassess and adapt your strategies based on the feedback and needs of the congregation.

Demonstrate humility and willingness to accept suggestions

Demonstrating humility is a significant step towards unity. Be open to suggestions and feedback from others. Let go of any pride that might hinder the process. Remember that unity is built on shared humility and a mutual willingness to work together, even when dealing with controversial issues.


Constructive engagement

In your Christian journey, you have seen the enduring relevance of churches in addressing contemporary controversies. They are more than just places of worship; they are spaces for dialogue, healing, and growth. 

It is crucial to remember that unity amidst disagreements is achievable. Your faith calls for constructive engagement, patience, and a willingness to listen and learn from one another. 

By doing so, you contribute to the strength and resilience of your church community. This makes it a beacon of light in a world often divided by differences.

More from Crossmap:

Going viral: Addressing hate comments


    Give

    Subscribe to the Daybreak Devotions for Women

    Be inspired by God's Word every day! Delivered to your inbox.


    More from Hannah

    Editor's Picks

    avatar

    Hannah

    I'm a Christian who sees the church as my second home. Not only were my parents the ones who raised me, but our church elders and members also played a significant role. However, despite attending church every Sunday, I still have some questions regarding my faith. As a writer, the articles I create serve as answers to the questions I've had and continue to have, and I hope they can serve a purpose for others who are searching for the same answers.

    More from Hannah